Skip to content
How polyamorous households split finances

Three incomes, one mortgage: How polyamorous households pay

Why Statistics Canada keeps revising its numbers

​Inside the Statistics Canada multiverse

Northern Ontario breweries are going bust

​Northern Ontario's brewery boom is going bust

Search

Latest Stories

​Carney's proposed tax credit for artists has a math problem

The budget contains the largest-ever investment in Canadian culture. But the Canada Creative Credit – the initiative meant to support artists most directly – is unlikely to make a financial difference for those who actually need it.

Oil painting of a $20 Canadian Bill

The federal budget includes a significant tax credit for artists – receiving the tax credit is another story.

The Margin Staff


Great news for CanCon fans: Carney’s 2026 fall budget boasts “the largest investment in culture in Canadian history.” The investment includes $783.1 million over five years to support national museums and other cultural institutions, as well as $32.2 million over four years to launch a free national digital library.

In addition to all this, Carney has taken one of his favourite policy tools – the tax break – and offered it to artists. The proposed Canada Creative Credit is “a non-refundable personal income tax credit that would, combined with the Basic Personal Amount, provide tax recognition on up to $45,000 of annual qualifying net business income.”

Personally – as much as I love to see more money in the arts – I’m not a huge fan of this proposed tax credit. For starters, it’s not as wide-ranging as it sounds. The tax credit is non-refundable, meaning it can cut the tax you owe down to zero, but it will never result in the government owing you a refund.

Plus, although the credit is advertised as applying to $45,000 of income, most Canadian taxpayers know that there’s already a basic personal amount you can earn without paying federal income tax, whether you’re an artist or not – somewhere between $14,800 to $16,500, depending on your net income. The $45,000 tax exemption promised by the Canada Creative Credit includes the Basic Personal Amount, rather than stacking on top of it, so it’s really only an exemption on an additional $28,500 or so.

The other major caveat to the Canada Creative Credit is that it only applies to “net business income,” which does not include employment income. So if you sell your own work, you could claim the credit. But if you earn wages or a salary as an artist, it won't be much help.

I truly don't mean to be a hater – Carney deserves credit (sorry) for funding culture at all – but this tax credit couldn't have been the best idea on the table. And if it was, I’m wondering whether there were any actual artists at that table.

As The Montreal Gazette reports, many Canadian artists don't clear the $45,000 threshold from arts-related income. Many don't even clear the $16,500 basic personal amount threshold. As visual artist Chris Boyne tells the Gazette, he's been a professional artist since 2002, showcasing his work across North America – and still, he says, “there are maybe three or four years where my income from being an artist has exceeded the basic amount of $16,000." In other words, Boyne has only needed to pay federal taxes on his artist income three or four times over the course of a 24 year career. Every other year, that income was covered by the basic personal amount.

Many, if not most, Canadian artists like Boyne make less than $16,000 from their creative work, and they still need to pay for rent and groceries somehow. Lots of artists – even established professionals – seek other streams of income, whether that’s teaching, applying for government grants, picking up freelance gigs in the corporate sector, or working shifts at their local cafe.

That’s another problem with the tax credit: someone has to decide what counts as art and who counts as an artist, and then those artists have to prove it.

As a writer, I can tell you how it works in my field. There are only a handful places in Canada that will publish short fiction for more than a couple hundred bucks; as of 2018, advances from book deals for un-agented authors averaged just $2,053. Agented authors fared better, at $17,340 – but even at that price, you could get four book deals a year and still not meet the median household income in Canada. (And, no offence, but if you’re writing four books a year, I’m not sure I trust that you actually wrote them.)

On the other hand, if you just want to move sentences around for money, there are plenty of less 'artistic' freelance gigs around. In her memoir Look Ma, No Hands (excerpted in The Walrus), Gabrielle Drolet chronicles some of the odd jobs she's taken as a professional writer: “I wrote Instagram captions for a hospital foundation. I wrote online content for a bank…I wrote a column where I recapped episodes of The Bachelorette.”

Would freelance Instagram captioning count as 'art' under the Canada Creative Credit? I suspect not, even though the future voices of Gen Z CanLit are probably doing exactly that right now to afford groceries. In fact, it’s very likely that none of these unglamorous income streams would be eligible for the Canada Creative Credit, even though these odd jobs provide the financial security for many artists to make their art.

Then again, we still don't know what will be eligible for the credit, since the definition of ‘art’ is so subjective. That’s another problem with the tax credit: someone has to decide what counts as art and who counts as an artist, and then those artists have to prove it. Already, the government’s narrow definitions of art make it difficult for certain types of creatives – like standup comedians, for example – to access grant money and to be represented in Canada's cultural policy.

So, what should the government do instead? (Carney, if you’re reading this, feel free to call me and discuss!)

One option is for the federal government to provide artists with basic income, meaning regular fixed payments that they can receive without working. This strategy was piloted in Ireland from 2022–2025, and a government-commissioned cost-benefit analysis (CBA) deemed it so successful that it became permanent policy earlier this year. The CBA concluded that “for every €1 of public money invested in the pilot, society received €1.39 in return” – though this figure does not just capture economic returns, but cultural outcomes and psychological impacts, too. (For someone who's been openly flirting with the EU, it’s a little surprising Carney wasn't inspired by this European experiment.)

Currently in Ireland, 2,000 eligible artists can receive a weekly stipend of €325 (around C$510) over a three-year term, presumably reducing the need for Instagram captioning gigs and freeing up time to make art. The amount of money on offer here is generous – more so than Carney’s proposed credit – but even a smaller amount paid out in less frequent intervals (say, monthly instead of weekly) would still benefit artists. As writer and basic income advocate Scott Santens points out in his Substack essay, the cadence of payments matters almost as much as the payments themselves. “Rent is monthly. Groceries are weekly,” he writes. “An artist deciding whether to take another shift or finish the album needs to know the money is coming next month, not hope for a smaller tax bill next year.”

For artists and cultural institutions, the Canada Creative Credit is, at the very least, an acknowledgement that they matter.

Even if Canada's not quite ready to provide basic income to artists, the government still has other options. Multiple arts workers suggest to the Montreal Gazette that robust investment in Canada Council for the Arts – a primary funding body for artists in Canada – should have taken precedence over the tax 1. Even increased funding to art programs at colleges and universities might make a bigger difference, in terms of allowing artists the financial flexibility to do their work. As Karla Étienne, Canadian Arts Coalition steering committee member, tells the Gazette, “if there’s no money to create…it’s hard for artists to have something to declare for a tax credit.”

Like I said at the outset, I’m really not trying to be a hater – it’s awesome that the federal government is paying attention to the arts. For artists and cultural institutions, the Canada Creative Credit is, at the very least, an acknowledgement that they matter. But it’s terrible math. If Bobby earns zero dollars from his unfinished literary masterpiece because he spends his days writing reality TV recaps to make rent, and he’s eligible for a $45,000 creative tax exemption, how much does he actually save? Zero minus zero is still zero.

credit 1 1

While the budget does promise $20 million over the next five years for Canada Council for the Arts, Canadian Arts Coalition has been lobbying for a $140 million investment.

More For You

Our newsletter is (much) better than this pop up

Plus: signing up means you'll never see this pop-up again. Score!